The Destructive Power of Belief — Future Hindsight
“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
George Santayana’s creative maxim is undoubtedly overused, but as the 21 stcentury lumbers through one avoidable catastrophe after another accidental nightmare, it isn’t overstated. The rest of the world watches with alarm as we openly flirt with fascism, fail to protect crumbling institutions, and stumble over even the most basic metrics of functioning society. It appears we’re living in a new terrifying reality in which no playbook applies, but that isn’t actually true. We live in the opening act of a tragic play with a clear script, and if we want to end the show at intermission, we need to read ahead.
To understand why fascism is again waiting in the wings and how we can use our knowledge to stop it from taking over center stage, we turned to renowned Nazi historian Nathan Stoltzfus. Stoltzfus is a history professor at Florida State University and the author of several books, including Hitler’s Compromises: Coercion and Consensus in Nazi Germany.
Listen to Mila’s interview with Nathan Stoltzfus here!
Stoltzfus didn’t waste time in assessing the most potent ingredient of Hitler’s brand of fascism: belief.
“For Hitler, what is important is belief,” he said. “It’s about belief and maintaining belief-how belief becomes important, and people buy into it. It becomes very difficult for them to shake that belief. It can cause a mental crisis.”
Nathan explained how Hitler decoupled Germany’s beliefs from reality, reinforcing the power of believing in Nazism, and most importantly, in Hitler.
“Hitler, as this leader, was protected in people’s minds, just like psychology has shown that people might protect their abusers,” Nathan told Mila. “One of these mechanisms of how Hitler moved forward-a very critical one-was that people believed in Hitler and they refused to blame him for anything that was wrong.”
Psychology supports Nathan’s assertions about the power of belief. Facts are bent, changed, used, or ignored-all based on our ideologies.
According to Hugo Mercier and Dan Sperber, the authors of The Enigma of Reason, reason helps us cooperate in social environments. We use reason to justify our beliefs and convince others to agree. Reason is excellent for community building but terrible for unbiased truth-seeking.
Since reason creates communities of like-minded thinkers like political parties, finding the truth in politics is extremely difficult. Several studies support the idea that deeply held, shared beliefs are nearly impossible to expel. One study found partisan math whizzes were much better at solving equations if the answer lined up with their political beliefs. Another study discovered politically savvy citizens with high IQs are great at making up arguments justifying a political stance, but only if they believe it.
Psychologists also discovered we like to reinforce our biases. We want consistent beliefs so severely we will refuse money if we can avoid opinions we don’t like. Worse, when we band together in a like-minded community, our shared ideas become even more extreme.
Hitler understood the power of belief, and endeavored to replace belief in Christianity with belief in national socialism. Hero worship is part and parcel of Nazi ideology, so Hitler also carefully and consistently crafted and nurtured a mythic image of himself as someone who was always striving for Germans on Germany’s behalf.
The idea of Hitler’s infallibility took hold across the nation and sometimes proved impossible to dispel.
“Once they start believing, the difficulty of pulling that prop out in their mental picture of reality,” Stoltzfus explained. “There were people who committed suicide because Hitler did. I remember hearing one person say when she heard Hitler committed suicide, ‘What do we do now? How can we possibly go forward?’”
This mental destruction speaks to a notion called the “backfire effect,” an instance of mental gymnastics that occurs when someone sees factual evidence contradicting their deeply-held belief. Many people react by doubling down, becoming even more sure in their ideas. Germans deified Hitler, and the facts of a Nazi loss and Hitler’s death went so deeply against their beliefs, suicide became an acceptable alternative.
Understanding how a weak, decidedly non-Aryan drug addict entranced so many Germans makes it easier to understand the red-capped crowds clamoring for a lying, cheating, businessman with six bankruptcies under his belt. Once the belief is there, no revelation of malfeasance is enough to shake it.
Althaus, S., LM. Arpan, A., Bartels, L., MA. Baum, P., MA. Baum, T., T. Brambor, W., . . . Zaller, J. (1998, January 01). When Corrections Fail: The Persistence of Political Misperceptions. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11109-010-9112-2
Frimer, J., Skitka, L., & Motyl, M. (2017, April 15). Liberals and conservatives are similarly motivated to avoid exposure to one another’s opinions. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0022103116304024
Glenn Kessler, S. (2020, October 02). Analysis | President Trump has made more than 20,000 false or misleading claims. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/07/13/president-trump-has-made-more-than-20000-false-or-misleading-claims/
Kahan, D., Peters, E., Dawson, E., & Slovic, P. (2013, September 08). Motivated Numeracy and Enlightened Self-Government. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2319992
MERCIER, H. (2019). ENIGMA OF REASON. Place of publication not identified: HARVARD UNIV Press.
Metro. (2020, February 24). All the Trump affairs we know about. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://www.metro.us/all-the-trump-affairs-we-know-about/
Moscovici, S., & Zavalloni, M. (1969). The group as a polarizer of attitudes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 12(2), 125–135. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0027568
Murse, T. (n.d.). The Details About the 6 Donald Trump Corporate Bankruptcies. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://www.thoughtco.com/donald-trump-business-bankruptcies-4152019
Perkins, D. N., Farady, M., & Bushey, B. (1991). Everyday reasoning and the roots of intelligence. In J. F. Voss, D. N. Perkins, & J. W. Segal (Eds.), Informal reasoning and education (p. 83–105). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Staff, N. (2017, March 07). Author Says Hitler Was ‘Blitzed’ On Cocaine And Opiates During The War. Retrieved October 15, 2020, from https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/03/07/518986612/author-says-hitler-was-blitzed-on-cocaine-and-opiates-during-the-war
Stoltzfus, N. (2016). Hitler’s compromises: Coercion and consensus in Nazi Germany. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Originally published at https://www.futurehindsight.com on October 16, 2020.